Skip to main content
You are the owner of this article.
You have permission to edit this article.
A.C. Weekly invites readers to vote for the top pies in South Jersey during ‘Pizza Palooza’
top story

A.C. Weekly invites readers to vote for the top pies in South Jersey during ‘Pizza Palooza’

  • 0


While New York may be the most famous spot for pizza in America, New Jersey has always had a great reputation when it comes to great pies, as well. But for years that reputation was really reserved for North Jersey. And that makes sense … after all, much of that region serves as a suburb to the Big Apple, and the large Italian population in the area meant that most of the top pizzerias in the state were going to be clustered in that general metropolis.

South Jersey on the other hand was for many years thought of as a pizza wasteland. Sure, there were a few exceptions, places like Tony’s Baltimore Grill and Manco & Manco have always been held in high regard, but as a whole, the area was rarely mentioned in the same breath as its neighbors to the north.

But as the years go by, it seems more and more truly outstanding pizza shops have made their way to our neck of the woods. Crusts have gotten crispier, sauces have gotten tangier and more than a few places have started to get a real buzz going, serving as more than just a remedy for people too lazy to cook on Friday night. Spots have popped up to raise the bar for what quality pizza means for our area.

And as the list of fantastic local pizzerias has grown, so has the loyalty of their customers. Which brings us to wonder — who really makes the best pizza in South Jersey?

It’s time to find an answer once and for all!

So with that goal in mind, we are proud to announce the launch of Pizza Palooza — a joint venture between Atlantic City Weekly critics and readers where we dig deep in search of the greatest slices in South Jersey.

The rules are simple: Tell us who makes your favorite pizza. Traditional plain pies only (Sicilian and grandma pies are OK, but no toppings or specialty pizza) — yes, we love a good buffalo chicken pizza, but that’s not what this is about. For this list, we’re keeping it simple.

There will be two divisions — a Top 10 critics’ picks — chosen by Scott Cronick and Ryan Loughlin (food writers and creators of Atlantic City Weekly’s popular Fat Boy Munch Club column), as well as a Top 10 for reader’s picks in which YOU will get to choose your favorite pie. Nominate any pizzeria you like within Atlantic County or Ocean City. Readers may vote for their favorite pizzeria once a day from Thursday, Feb. 4, through Sunday, March 7. Pizzas will be ranked based on who gets the most votes. Winners will be featured in an upcoming issue of Atlantic City Weekly.

Below is the list, but we need you to vote for your favorite – or nominate some we may have missed – at

Hungry yet? Good. Order a few pies and get voting!

Below is a list of local pizzerias in case you forgot who is slinging slices in our area. Don’t see your favorite? Add it on our voting page at


Black Cat Bar & Grill

Calabria Pizza & Italian Grill

Hangtime Bar & Grille

The Hi-Point Pub

Joe & John’s Italian Restaurant

Roman’s Pizza House

Sack O’s Subs

Villa Rifici

Atlantic City

AC Popa Pizza,

Buca di Beppo

Chelsea Pizza II

Chickie’s & Pete’s

Cuzzie’s Pizzeria & Kitchen

Famiglia Pizza

Fiesta Pizza

Gino’s Pizza


Grotto Ristorante

Jonuzi’s Pizza

The Original LoPresti’s Pizza & Grill

Perry’s Pizza

Pizza Di Roma

Pizata Pizza and Pasta

Tony’s Baltimore Grill

Tony Boloney’s

Wingcraft Kitchen & Beer Bar


Andre’s Wine Bar & Grill

Aversa’s Italian Bakery

Bella Luna

The Cellar 32

Goochie Brothers Italian

McHugh’s Pizza Brigantine


Mi Familia Pizza

Villa Fazzolari

Egg Harbor City

2 Brothers from Italy

Gennaro’s Italian Grille & Pizzeria

Matarazzo’s Family Pizzeria & Restaurant

Piasano’s Pizzeria

South End Pizza IV

Special Pizza City

Tailgater’s Sports Bar & Grille

Egg Harbor Township

III Brothers Pizza

Chickie’s & Pete’s

Dino’s Deli and Subs

Eat at Joe’s EHT

Gaspare’s Italian Bistro

Juliano’s Pub & Grill

Maurizio’s Pizzeria Express

Micchelli’s Pizza

Jo-Jo’s Italian Grille EHT

Pizza Beni

Pizza Di Palermo

South End Pizza III

Special Pizza City

Tulipano Pizza and Grill

Walt’s Original Primo Pizza

Galloway Township

Costello’s Pizzeria & Wings

Giovanni’s Pizza

Gourmet Italian Cuisine & Pizzeria

Jo-Jo’s Pizza & Restaurant

McHugh’s Pizza Galloway

Napoli Pizza Grill

Pitney Pub

Purdy’s Galloway Grill

Romanelli’s Garden Cafe

Two Brothers from Italy

Vincenzo’s Smithville


Andy’s Pizza & Ristorante

Brother’s Pizza

Bruni’s Pizzeria

Corrado’s Pizza & Wings

Illiano’s Ristorante

Mario’s Pizza

Nino’s Pizzerama

Ricca Brothers Brick Oven Pizzeria

Vinny’s Pizzeria


Bakeria 1010

La Pizza Tega

Mays Landing

Cheech 2 Go

Cosimo’s Pizza

Cousin Mario’s Italian Restaurant & Bar

Frankie’s Pizza II

Godfather’s Italian Grill

Jo Ann’s Pizza & Restaurant II

Maurizio’s Pizzeria & Italian

Nino’s Pizza Festival

Route 40 Pizza & Restaurant


Caffe Luciano Lamberti


Aversa’s Italian Bakery


Bocca Coal Fired Bistro

Dino’s Subs & Pizza

Jonuzi Chelsea Pizza

Maynard’s Café

Pierre’s Pizza

Robert’s Place


Ventura’s Greenhouse Restaurant


Capri Pizza & Grill

Carluccio’s Coal Fired Pizza

Chico & Sons

La Cucina Ristorante

Little Italy Pizzeria & Restaurant

Nick’s Pizza

Valentina’s Trattoria Italiana

Ventura’s Offshore Cafe

Ocean City

6th Street Pizza and Grill


Big Slice

Luigi’s Italian Restaurant

Manco & Manco Pizza

Mario’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

Piccini Wood Fired Brick Oven Pizza

Pisa Pizza

Prep’s Pizzeria and Dairy Bar


Randazzo Pizzeria & Family Restaurant

Roma Pizza

Sack O’ Pizza & Pasta

Santucci’s Original Square Pizza

Three Brothers from Italy Pizza

Voltaco’s Italian Foods


Johnny D’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

Jo-Jo’s Italian Grille

JV’s Pizza & Mexican Restaurant

Marco Polo Pizzeria

Pepe’s Pizza by Modesto

Pizza di Roma

Pizza Party

Somers Point

Amici’s Homemade Specialties

Italian Street Restaurant and Pizza

Joe’s Mediterranean Grill

and Pizza and Sub Shop

The Local’s Spot (inside Caroline’s)

Manco & Manco

Marsini’s Kitchen

Micchelli’s Pizza

Romano’s Pizza

Sal’s Coal Fired Pizza

Walt’s Original Primo Pizza


Capri Pizza

Pulia Ristorante

Sack O’Subs

Santucci’s Original Square Pizza


Uncle Gino’s Pizza & Ristorante

Zorro’s Pizza

How did pizza become an American craze?

Though many Italian foods have become popular in America, pizza here is a true obsession. Originally introduced to cities on the East Coast of the U.S. by immigrants from its birthplace in Naples, Italy, pizza began to take off when the concept of the slice was invented; meaning folks no longer had to purchase an entire pie when they just wanted a quick lunch or dinner. The first pizzeria stateside was Lombardi’s, which opened up in New York City in 1905, and is still serving hungry patrons today. Our passion for it has grown ever since, even rising to the level of other adopted favorites like hot dogs, tacos or even the almighty hamburger, as the nearly religious American devotion to dough topped with tomato sauce and cheese almost makes pizza seem more like an American dish than an Italian one. And according to, it kinda is:

“Shortly after its introduction stateside, pizza became more popular in the U.S. than it was in Italy. This is partly because pizza’s not exactly Italian to begin with. Naples was originally founded by Greek settlers around 600 BC, and pizza is known to have existed there before the city was unified with the rest of Italy in 1861. The cheesy, tomatoey delight wasn’t introduced into greater Italian cuisine until the 1940s. So, at least for a while, pizza was much more American than Italian.”

Whatever country takes the credit, the pizza craze has remained in this nation for more than a century with no signs of slowing down anytime soon. And that’s just fine with us.


Be the first to know

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

This year, let’s set an intention to expand our Wine IQ. Here are seven DIY experiments that you can produce, at home, with a friend or small group.

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.